It seems the theif, after removing all cash and change and the credit/debit cards, rubberbanded my driver's license to the front of my wallet and dropped it in a mailbox.
It took this long to get to us because I had the wrong zip code on the license (this was corrected in the replacement.) It also cost us $2.12 postage. :/
I've of course replaced the credit and debit cards, and the license, but I did get my insurance cards, my AAA card and my Reader's Advantage card from Barnes and Noble back, so that's a good thing. I'd forgotten about the AAA card. Also a little mincha-ma'ariv book which I've also replaced but Jonathan can use it.
So. At least I got that. Sort of a Chanukah present.