?

Log in

No account? Create an account
Mama Deb
mamadeb
.:::.:....... ..::...:
Mama Deb [userpic]

Yeah, bored again.


Yesterday, I posted a humor story for the Gay Wedding challenge. (It's on mamadebfic.) And it was one of the hardest stories I've written for a long time - I rewrote a story that ended up maybe 1.2K four or five times, plus endless rehearsals in my mind.

Humor is hard in the best of circumstances. It's easy to make people cry; it's difficult to make them laugh, and since the process of rewriting wrings out emotional content, especially the funny, it's impossible to know if it even works until someone reads it.

It's even harder in a universe with a major war (as far as the characters are concerned; the Muggle world is probably completely unaware of it. This, by the way, is the genius of the first few chapters of OotP. Rowling paints such a picture of mundane suburbia - news programs with water-skiing budgies, drought and lawns, playgrounds and hydrangea bushes - that Harry's wand, Mundungus' Apparation and the Dementors are shocking. The Wizarding world doesn't touch this one. But I digress. Often.)in the offing.

War means death. In the last war, a good part of the Order died, and we know a lot of noncombatants died as well. In the current war, we've lost four people that we know about - Quirrelmort, Cedric, Bode and Sirius. Rowling has already said that there will be more death in the upcoming book, and will not promise that Harry will surivive. How does one write a fluffy postwar story when one has to acknowledge that people aren't there anymore? I managed, I hope, but I had to slip in mention of the loss of various characters, and leave others out.

So, here is purest speculation.

1. Ron will die. He's a sidekick, and sidekicks buy it more often than heroes. He's also a sidekick who is rising beyond that status. He's already a prefect and he may well become Head Boy; he's playing Keeper when Harry can't (Quidditch, I predict, will become even less important, but Quidditch skills will figure greatly in the rest of the books.) and may captain the team since Angelina left after Book 5. This is going to be a problem.

However, we have a couple of clues. The first is the infamous chess game. Ron could easily have been killed there - I think he was expecting it, but it makes sense that McGonagall would not have made her game lethal. Just incapacitating. Ron wasn't to know that, though. He chose his move knowing he could die, and he did with his eyes wide open. If he could do it at twelve (his age at that point), he can do it at 18.

The second is the Christmas luncheon in book 3. "When thirteen dine together, the first to leave the table will be the first to die." Granted, this is Trelawney, and it could be there to show how silly she is, but I think there is more to it than that. Ron and Harry get up at more or less the same time, which would indicate that one of them will die first. If Harry dies, it'll be right at the end of Book 7, so, if it's him, everyone else will live past the books. If Ron dies first, though, that can happen at any point. And stripping Ron away from Harry will make him desperate enough to do anything, I think.

So I think Ron will die. I think it'll happen somewhere after the middle of book 7, and before any of the regular teachers - McGonagall, Snape, Flitwick, Dumbledore - do. If they do.

In more pleasant speculation, we have romance. I'm a slasher, but I'm not silly. I don't expect to see any of my pairings happen. The most likely one doesn't exist anymore, anyway. As for het pairings - Rowlings keeps pointing to Ron/Hermione. Except that Viktor is still in the picture and Luna has a massive crush on Ron (she calls him Ronald and sings "Weasley is our King" under her breath, and only seems to pay attention to him when he's around.)

I have no great problems with this. He's loyal. He's kind (he's the one who thinks to give Dobby another pair of socks so he can mix and match them). He adopts Harry straight off. And he's not stupid. He's too good at chess to be stupid, and too bright for that to be his only talent. He's even good at Keeping once he relaxes. Otherwise, yes, he's ordinary.

Hermione is brilliant at everything she does, and she has some basic understanding of human emotion, but she is a bit of a prig and rather self-righteous. Nicely complex, just like Ron. I like her, and I like him, and I don't think they'd make a bad pair. They'd bicker happily forever, you know?

But that's not why I don't mind. See, at this point, they're both sidekicks - more or less equal, other than the fact that Harry sleeps in the same room as Ron. They're even both prefects now. If they become a couple, they're still both sidekicks and more or less equal, except they may spend less time with Harry and more with each other. If they date other people - Viktor or Luna - the same thing happens. Even if one has a romance and the other doesn't, the Trio is their primary relationship and the friendship doesn't change.

If, however, Hermione starts dating Harry, she becomes The Girlfriend. And Girlfriends have different roles than Best Friends, and are perceived differently. And I don't want that fate for Hermione. (I don't want it for Ron, either, even if I didn't believe he was a Kinsey 1 - not a gay bone in his body.)

As for Harry - he's too busy to think about dating. It's too much mental effort for someone who has the weight of his world on his shoulders. Let him survive book 7 first.

Comments

May I offer a free title to the slash world?

Harry Potter and the Well-Hung Prince

*runs away veryveryveryfast*

I dunno. All indications are that Hermione has chosen Ron, and when he gets his head back out into the sunshine, he'll choose her back. I don't see the literary need to kill him off yet, though it's possible.

My vote on a death in book 6 is for McGonnagall. There's been speculation -- which I can't contradict, and might well believe -- that she's Draco Malfoy's grandmother. There have been several points where she has acted less than 100% in support of Harry, Dumbledore, and the Good Guys (though nothing blatant), and I could see her easily being forced into a position where she finally defies her blackmailer (Lucius?), comes back to the GG's side, and gets killed as a result.

Of course, Viktor could get himself killed, too, as a consequence of heroing for Hermione (and wouldn't that be a good band name? :-) [pardon me while I finish channeling autographedcat *ahem* done now :-] or standing up to the Dark Lord who seems to own Durmstrang.

Either way, we'll see what's what and who's who in a little over six months. Have fun, until then!

I don't see Ron dying in book *6*. He's too important to the overall story - he's pretty much Harry's Id. The Heart, if you will. And Harry without a Heart would be a terrible thing, wouldn't he?

Can you tell those points about McGonagall? Because I haven't picked up on them and I'm curious. Then again, I haven't looked. :) I see her as scrupulously fair except as regards Quidditch. (Also, she was at the table that Christmas.)

She's also nearly died already.

I don't want to even think about who should die in Book 6. I just know it'll be someone close to Harry. So a teacher is a good bet.


we've lost four people that we know about - Quirrelmort, Cedric, Bode and Sirius.

Don't forget Bertha Jorkins! And the Muggle gardener, what's-his-name, at the Riddle house.

Thank you. I forgot Bertha and Frank. Very bad of me. So the number is six.

Only books 2 and 3 haven't had deaths occur in them. Some children's series.

Some children's series.

The *good* kind. Speaking as someone who's in the middle of "Taran Wanderer" as read-aloud time -- the Prydain series never pulls punches about the "not everyone here gets out alive" thing.

Just a quick interruption to squee at finding another Prydain fan. Read it myself, my husband read it to our son (who then took it back to his room and reread like a million times) - wonderful series. And yeah, not everyone gets out alive.

Erm, what about Teh Martyrs James and Lily?

I'm counting them as the last casualties of the last war.

Yeah, sorry, it was re: "Some children's series" ;)

My predictions:

Someone of increasing importance dies.

Hermione and Ron realize their love for each other.

JK Rowling goes on and on and on for an abysmal amount of pages on either (a) unnecessary angst or (b) ridiculous subplots no one cares about, or (c) both, because no one's editing her anymore. Then she swims in piles and piles of pound coins, like Scroog McDuck.

You mean, more Hagrid chapters? Oh, please, no. I skip those now on reread.

We can take heart that this one is, reportedly, shorter.

Is it nasty of me to hope that Hagrid dies horribly?

Don't get me wrong. I *like* Hagrid. (It's not wrong of anyone to dislike him. I just disagree.) I just find his chapters in OotP to drag horribly. Which they didn't in Chamber of Secrets.

you skip hagrid stuff too? good i'm not the only one! hagrid annoys me and i dont quite understand why everyone is so obsessed with him....

also...what's a Kinsey?

I only skip the Hagrid chapters in OotP. I *like* him and his huge heart. He's not a great teacher, but neither are Binns or Snape. And Snape's class deals with highly volatile material that can and has caused explosions and damage. (Not excusing the Skrewts, of course - those were idiotic - but Grubbly-Plank's first lesson was adult unicorns, which meant that fully half the students had to stay far away. When Hagrid took over, he gave them baby unicorns so everyone could learn. And given Kettleburn's reason for retiring, one does wonder what creatures he taught.)

And he was the first person in Harry's memory to do anything nice for him, or to defend him against his relatives. He's not perfect, but I like him.

i didn't think about it that way. clearly you have thought about this more than i have :)

hagrid annoys me, but i dont dislike him.

Re: Kinsey

Dr. Kinsey was the original sex researcher. He's the subject of a current biopic, actually.

The Kinsey scale is the measure of one's seuxality. It goes from 1 - never having had a gay thought in one's life - to 5 - never having had a straight thought in one's life.

Most people fall somewhere inbetween.

oh! and i've never heard of him....i guess those psych classes were wasted

I like your insights into the Ron-Hermione-Harry trio and how inter-trio romance might or might not affect their dynamics. Very cool.

Thank you!

Saw this on my flist...God, I hope you're wrong that it's Ron! My heart hurt reading your speculation because it sounds absolutely possible and I will so very sad if we lose him. [crosses fingers] Please let it be Percy!

P.S. friending you!

I don't want it to be Ron, either.

And take heart - I'm usually wrong at these things. :)

Thank you!