Heck, I thought for sure it was going to be Elliot!

They had three very different guys who can all sing. Elliot's voice is gorgeous and you forget what he sings right afterwards. Taylor's voice is gorgeous, but he's hard to watch.

Chris' voice is gorgeous, and he rocks. And he gave me chills with "Love Me, Tender" tonight.

And Katharine? Screeches.

For some reason I found this week to be Chris' weakest - though his leaving still shocked the heck out of me. And Katharine always seems to sing much better in the rehearsal bits than she does on stage. But then, she's the last 'conventionally attractive' one left, so she might get the shallow votes.